Skip to main content
Loading…
This section is included in your selections.

A. Applicability. An applicant may seek an alteration of a critical area and/or critical area buffer through a permitted alteration when application of the standards in this chapter would result in the denial of all reasonable and economically viable use of the property and the proposed development meets the specific terms of this section.

B. General Requirements. The actions in the permitted alteration table, Table 19.70.045, must be considered permitted alterations, unless as otherwise specified under AMC 19.70.230, Specific wetland category development standards, and provided they are consistent with the general standards for mitigation sequencing and other applicable requirements established in this chapter.

C. Review Process.

1. A critical area permit must be required for all permitted alterations. Requests for such permits must be reviewed using the procedures outlined in AMC Chapter 19.20, Table 19.20.030-1, Review classification and process matrix. No permit must be issued unless it can be shown that the proposed development is fully consistent with the requirements of this chapter.

2. In addition to other project-related documents, all permitted alterations must require a critical area assessment report per AMC 19.70.115, Critical area report, to evaluate the permitted alteration. The report must include:

a. A description of the function and condition of the critical area and/or buffer that would be altered;

b. An analysis of the effect of the development proposal on the critical area and/or buffer;

c. A description of actions that can be taken to modify the development proposal to avoid or reduce the alteration of the critical area and/or buffer and a discussion of whether these modifications are practical and reasonable;

d. A mitigation plan as required by this chapter.

3. Burden of Proof. The burden of proof is on the applicant to bring forth evidence in support of the application and upon which any decision has to be made on the application.

4. Public Comment. Consistent with AMC 19.20.030, Types of review, the city must ensure the opportunity for public comment, including that from appropriate federal, state, and tribal natural resource agencies, to ensure the use of best available science before deciding on approval.

D. Decision Criteria. A permit for alterations of a critical area and/or buffer width requirements of this chapter may only be issued if the applicant demonstrates that all of the following criteria are met:

1. Special circumstances applicable to the subject property, including size, shape, or topography, and the strict application of this chapter is found to deprive the subject property of rights and privileges enjoyed by other properties in the vicinity; provided, however, that the fact that those surrounding properties have been developed under regulations in force prior to the adoption of this chapter may not be the sole basis for granting approval;

2. The issuance of a variance to zoning requirements (setback, height, coverage, etc.) by itself will not provide sufficient relief to avoid the need for a permitted alteration to the critical area and/or buffer and other requirements for the critical areas regulated by this chapter;

3. Mitigation sequencing per AMC 19.70.125(A), Mitigation Sequencing, has been applied;

4. The proposed alteration is supported by best available science; and

5. The proposed alteration allows for development of the subject parcel with the least impact on critical areas while providing a reasonable use of the property.

E. Conditions May Be Required. In granting any approval, conditions and safeguards may be prescribed as are necessary to secure adequate protection of critical areas from adverse impacts, protect adjacent property, and ensure conformity with this chapter.

F. Table 19.70.045 describes activities that must meet the precise description to be allowed following the prescribed critical area process. Activities are divided into the categories of permitted in the critical area and permitted in the buffer, marked by a yes or no in the appropriate column.

Table 19.70.045 Permitted Activities

Permitted Alterations: (Critical Area Permit Required – Type 2 Administrative Decision)

Critical Area

Buffer

Buffer Modifications, including: increased buffer width, buffer averaging, and buffer alterations as described specifically in this chapter.

No

Yes

Public Services. To protect wetlands, streams, wildlife habitat and other sensitive critical areas while allowing services when the strict application of the standards in this chapter would otherwise unreasonably prohibit the provision of public services and amenities.

Yes

Yes

1. “Public services” include, but are not limited to, water supply, sewer and stormwater management facility; electric power, telecommunication and natural gas lines; and public road and multimodal transportation corridors (e.g., the Tommy Thompson Trail and Guemes Channel Trail).

2. Public services may be allowed to alter critical areas and buffers when:

a. Mitigation sequencing per AMC 19.70.125(A) has been applied;

b. The application of the critical areas regulations would unreasonably restrict the ability to provide public services;

c. There is no other practical alternative to the proposed development with less impact on the critical area;

d. The proposed development does not create a health or safety hazard on or off the development site, and must not be detrimental to the properties or improvements in the vicinity;

e. Where feasible, development is located on existing road grades, utility corridors, or previously disturbed areas;

f. Designs for crossings, boardwalks, bridges, and culverts are consistent with Washington Department of Fish and Wildlife and National Marine Fisheries Service best available science for the protection of fish and wildlife habitat. These structures shall not interfere with fish passage, the flow and circulation of water, or other wetland or riparian processes, and shall be located at a 90-degree angle, or as close as possible thereto, to the stream, wetland, or buffer. In streams with salmonid habitat, bridges, bottomless culverts, or other alternatives that will allow for fish passage are required. Bridge piers or abutments may not be placed within wetlands, streams, or stream banks unless there is no feasible alternative;

g. Construction of crossings will occur during work windows and time limits established by state and federal agencies with jurisdiction to decrease impacts to protected species;

h. Any alterations permitted to the critical area and buffer are mitigated in accordance with AMC 19.70.125, Mitigation requirements, and relevant mitigation standards for the impacted critical areas(s) type;

i. The proposal is consistent with the Anacortes comprehensive plan and other applicable regulations.

3. Conditions Authorized. Conditions may be established as necessary to mitigate impacts to critical areas and to conform to the standards required in this chapter.

4. It will be a condition of any alteration granted a public agency and services exception that only the portion of the alteration that must be located in a critical area may be so located.

Conservation, Restoration, and Fish Habitat Enhancement Projects. Conservation or restoration activities aimed at protecting or enhancing the soil, water, vegetation, or wildlife; including voluntary fish, wildlife, and wetland restoration or enhancement activities not required as project mitigation that have been approved by the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service, the Washington State Department of Ecology, Washington State Department of Fish and Wildlife, or other appropriate local, state, federal, or tribal jurisdiction and/or that meet the criteria of RCW 77.55.181(1) and that are reviewed and approved according to the provisions of RCW 77.55.181. A biological evaluation report is required to determine whether the proposal would conserve, preserve, or enhance critical area functions in the long term to minimize temporary environmental impacts.

Yes

Yes

Chemical Applications. The application of herbicides, pesticides, organic or mineral-derived fertilizers, or other hazardous substances, if necessary for the control of nuisance weeds and algae; except that their use will be restricted in accordance with the Washington Department of Ecology and Washington Department of Fish and Wildlife management recommendations, and regulations of the Washington State Department of Agriculture and the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency.

Yes

Yes

Recreational Areas/Facilities. Low impact activities which are consistent with the purpose and function of the critical area buffer (not to include the ACFL) and do not detract from its integrity may be permitted within the buffer depending on the sensitivity of the critical area.

No

Yes

1. Limited public park or public recreational access including trails, viewing platforms, fishing access (no wider than six feet), and foot bridges; provided, that all of the following are satisfied:

a. The area/facility is part of a public park that is dependent on its location for recreational function; and

b. The area/facility is limited to the minimum necessary to accomplish the recreational function; and

c. The removal of trees and native vegetation is minimized; and

d. The balance of the development is consistent with other requirements of this chapter; and

e. The project is identified in the Anacortes comprehensive plan or parks master plan.

2. Private pedestrian walkways and public trails must meet the following standards:

a. The trail is generally parallel to the perimeter of the critical area;

b. The trail is located in the outer 25 percent of the buffer area and is designed to avoid removal of trees and native vegetation;

c. The trail does not exceed six feet in width, and is limited to native soils or pervious surfaces. Raised boardwalks utilizing nontreated pilings may be acceptable; and

d. The trail may be subject to closure during critical spawning, migration or breeding time periods of sensitive species that are present.

3. Informational Signs. Construction and placement of informational signs or educational demonstration facilities no more than nine square feet surface area and four feet high, as long as there is no permanent infringement on hydrology or stream flow and nontreated wood is used.

4. Limited excavating and filling necessary for the repair and maintenance of piers, walkways, observation decks, wildlife management shelters, boathouses, and other similar water related structures, provided they are built on pilings to allow unobstructed flow of water and preserve the natural contour of the critical area.

Single-Family Residences and Normal Appurtenances. New single-family dwellings on existing legal lots may intrude into critical areas or their buffers when all of the following conditions are met:

Yes

Yes

1. It is demonstrated that it is not feasible to avoid the critical area or buffer through avoidance or buffer averaging, or reconfiguration of lots in the same ownership at the date of adoption of this chapter, and the development is the minimum necessary to achieve reasonable use of the lot as determined by the decision-maker; and

2. Alteration of critical areas and their buffers including all clearing, grading, structures, and appurtenances, has not and will not exceed cumulatively 2,800 square feet of disturbance; and

3. This action does not allow critical areas or their buffers to be converted to lawn or residential landscaping beyond a minimal area needed to maintain an approved structure; and

4. Mitigation sequencing provided in this chapter under AMC 19.70.125 is applied and the proposal includes on-site mitigation to the extent feasible and off-site mitigation to the extent necessary, as determined by the critical area report.

5. Normal appurtenances included in this provision include garages, decks, and walkways incidental to residential living and that do not constitute a special privilege.

Anacortes Community Forest Lands. Given the unique qualities of the community forest, all properties designated as ACFL have been nominated as a regulated critical area. Any and all new uses and development of new facilities within the ACFL must meet the requirements of the conservation easements/deed restrictions of the land, Anacortes comprehensive plan, the ACFL comprehensive plan, this chapter, and AMC Chapter 8.10, Parks and the Anacortes Community Forest Lands.

Yes

Yes

Critical Area Aquifer Recharge Areas. All regulated activities listed under AMC 19.70.515, Applicability and hazardous materials questionnaire.

Yes

Yes

(Ord. 4025 § 2 (Att. A), 2022; Ord. 3064 § 2 (Att. A), 2021)